Fuse position?

Started by Rogal118
4 replies 9 likes Last activity: 6 days ago
#5 3
If the boat only has a single motor then place the fuse between the battery and the speed controller, as close to the battery as possible.

The the boat has has multiple motors each with its own speed controller then place a separate fuse between the battery and each speed controller, as close to the battery as possible.

If the boat has multiple motors powered by the same battery and the same speed controller then place a fuse between each motor and the speed controller. Next place a fuse between the battery and the speed controller. The fuse protecting each motor should be a slow-blow fuse sized to blow a bit under the stall current of the motor. The fuse protecting the battery, wiring and speed controller should be sized above the stall current of a single motor, but below the point at which fire in the wiring (yes I've seen that happen on fast electric boats) or damage to the battery or damage to the speed controller occurs. With this seizure of a single motor will blow its fuse but allow the other motor(s) to continue operation.

In electrical engineering this is known as 'Discrimination' or "Selectivity'.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selectivity_(circuit_breakers)

It should be realized that staring current of a motor is higher than the running current. A fast blowing has a good chance of blowing under normal operating conditions, particularly quickly going from full ahead to full astern.
Liked by Rogal118 and RNinMunich and
#4 3
I think both Hermank and BobbyN gave an excellent answer.

However, I had a (very cheap) ESC that was defective and already short-circuiting. Luckily, it was a test.
In that case, a fuse between the ESC and the battery would have saved the cables, which had melted all the insulation. Luckily, I had time to disconnect everything and save the battery.
The causes of shorts or overloads are probably more likely between the ESC and the motor because the motor is more prone to stalling (if the propeller jams) and therefore increasing the current intensity to dangerous levels, but I wouldn't rule anything out.
In my opinion, it should be placed both between the ESC and the battery and between the ESC and the motor.

I would use both.
Liked by IanTurk and Rogal118
#3 3
We always place the fuse between the battery and ESC as this protects the ESC. The attached wiring diagram is what we use in our association
#1 3

Fuse position?

Good morning everyone. Quick question, what is the best position to place the fuse, between the battery and speed controller, or speed controller and motor.i intend to use 12v 7 ah battery, a “hobby wing quicrun 1060” 60a speed controller, and a mfa919d- 4.5/15v brushed motor. Any help and thoughts will be greatly appreciated. Thanks Rogal.
Roger
Liked by chugalone100 and AlessandroSPQR

Sign in to add to this thread.

Delete this post?

It will be removed from the site.

Discard this draft?

Your draft will be deleted and cannot be recovered.

You have an unfinished draft

What would you like to do with it?