Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
A few years ago I was fortunate enough to be given a conducted tour of 2757 at Hendon and was able to get photographs of the internals of the wheelhouse and engine room. I haven't been down recently but I hope she gets preserved under cover. Work had been going on to replace some deck planking and fill some holes in the hull. With the weight of engines removed hull distortion should have been eased a bit. Regards, John
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Have you seen this Page?
http://www.ournewhaven.org.uk/page_id__1928.aspx?path=0p69p87p104p
Some interesting stuff about 2754 and 2760 from 'folks who were there'!
Cheers, Doug 😎
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
I have just relocated some of the files I had from when I did my build of the RTTL and I came across these two photographs of the 2760 Launch and I am sure I have some written work somewhere about her. I will have a look - but - some of my 'old' files are on a computer hardrive from the old computer
www.rafboats.co.uk
John
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
The RAF also sent a Javelin squadron to neighbouring Zambia - The RhodAF Hunters & RAF Javelins used to do dawn patrols wingtip to wingtip down Lake Kariba - when asked by a RhodAF pilot as to what the RAF pilot would do if ordered to attack - the response was "have immediate radio failure"...........If A RTTL was set afloat in Kariba from Zambia Whitehall would have been fully aware that it would have been almost instantly blown out of the water by RhodAF or the RR Artillery should it venture out. So not very likely - also the it would have been a nightmare journey as most of Zambias good were delivered through Rhodesia..........The other routes would have been impassable and air delivery does not seem feasible.
The only other Naval activity involving Rhodesia occurred during WW1 when the Launches Mimi & TuTu passed through on their way to Lake Victoria to do battle with the German gunboats. They were guided by a Rhodesian "Big Game" hunter who had proposed the whole thing in the first place but he left after an argument with the eccentric Commander Spicer Spencer the RN had decided to put in charge..........
Thorneycroft built two small gunboats for use on the Pungwe river by Rhodesia - (the river is only navigable some 20 miles inland - well within Mozambique)- but I have never found any record or documentation for them other than a small item in a Thorneycroft history article read somewhere long ago.............
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
The other one I enjoyed, although it is more of an auto-biography, is "Boat in the Blue" by W.D. Pereira.
Not very long but I enjoyed it.
Rowen
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
As an Air Cadet I visited them at Mountbatten one Saturday in the mid 1970’s and got dragged behind one when doing my parachute/dingy training in the mid 1980’s! up in Holyhead Harbour!
I bought the book on eBay last night so I can’t wait to read more about their exploits with us Aircrew!
Thanks again. Graham 😎
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
I am sure you will find the book interesting, I learnt a lot particularly about the difficulties in rescue in the war.
I have a vested interest in you liking this message as I am one point away from promotion from 2 nd class to 1 st class, actually looking at the note on the LH side of my screen this message is worth two points, so shall have promoted myself.
Your project has got me into a bit of research into the RTTL's. When I was at Mount Batten there was probably about 5 there then. My billet was on the third floor and we overlooked the Sound, when a RTTL came in it had a very characteristic sound, even with the engine no doubt at a low speed.
We used to do daily radio checks on them, but did not get rides, as they usually, when they went out it was for some time and it was not appreciated if you disappeared for all day. We used to get lots of rides on the Range Safety Launches as these did dingy drill for air crew and you could arrange to be doing a radio check, when they were going out beyond the breakwater to dump the pilot into the sea with his un inflated life dingy.
I did have one day out on a Mk 2 RTTL, but only across the sound and then to anchor there for the day on a nuclear attack exercise. I was glad to get back after rocking back and forward for six hours, it would have given the crew a lot of enjoyment if I had been sick.
I did have another much more enjoyable ride on the one remaining Napier Sea Lion powered Mk 1A RTTL that was still at Mount Batten, I think it had been kept for historical reasons and had not been modified to fit Griffons. As far as I was aware it was never used operationally, although we did daily radio checks. One day I found out that it was to be given a test run so arranged to be on it when it went out on test. It was a lovely sunny day and the sea was calm, we got outside the breakwater and the engines were opened up but the trip at speed did not last very long as one of the engines failed, but we still had two left so could return to the Cattewater safely. It may have been the last day that a RTTL ever ran on Napier power.
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
It would seem unlikely to me that anyone would have taken the risk of attaching an explosive charge to it before it finally sank. In my time when involved with the RAF marine craft activities, some 15 years before the loss of '54, there was very little of any interest to any foreign power on board, other than perhaps the engines.
I do not know if the main long range radio system was ever replaced as in 1961/62 it was the system used by the RAF in the Second World War i.e. 1154 receiver and 1155 transmitter. On my radio course at Yatesbury we were told that you will never see one of these in service so we spent the two days allocated to this equipment listening to the BBC on the receiver. Luckily there was a civilian engineer who knew these units and he kept them going.
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Will be posting Episode 1 of mine on RTTL 2762E shortly.
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Brilliant.
You really have a good restoration project in your hands.
I would love to get my hands on your motor and give it TLC.
I am afraid I like so many others on this site I really believe in the ethos of don’t replace it if it isn’t broken.
Good luck and Yes, go for the blog.
Regards Bill.👍🍷🍷
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Honestly.
I wouldn’t be too keen to disregard the existing motor.
It will remain part of the character of your boat,very important.
It is so easy to throw out the old and put in a new one,which is not always the answer.
I have a motor in one of my corvette’s that is 40 years old ..It’s as good as new.
Yes,! If is giving you troubles and you can’t get parts,then,when that occurs,replace.
As I said,and Doug reiterated give it a good session of TLC and see how it goes.
It’s all about, preserving what you have in many cases.
Regards Bill
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
John
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
If we really do want to be a 'purist' about these vessels.
They were renowned for splitting their hulls as they crashed into waves. This was due to the fact that the propellers rotated in the same direction - causing the boat to corkscrew and dive into the oncoming wave. To counteract this, there were several attempts - one being to fit a triangular wedge shape at the stern of the hull and if you look at one of the photographs I have put on - you will be able to make out at the stern above the rudder a very slim wedge shape this was an RTTL that was being scrapped.
The second thing they attempted was to add a 3rd layer of planking to the bottom of the hull. This wasn't very successful either.
Just some food for thought. Also, here are a couple of my build photographs and the motors I put in - and the wedge I put on the stern.
Also a couple of blueprints which you may already have of the vessel.
John
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Rowen
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
BTW
Congrats on your promotion, long overdue!
New insignia attached.
Next step the 'Scrambled Egg hat' 😁
Cheers, FLEET//😎
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Doubt you would forget where your boat sank out from under you!
Rowen
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Sea Lion - Sabre?
i don't think so, the Sea Lion was 12 cylinder W block ca 500HP, the Sabre was a 24 cylinder engine with 5 to 7 times the power of the Sea Lion. (2200 developed to 3500HP).
Cheers, Doug 😎
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Just found this on the BMPT site
"I served on 2754 Gibraltar 1971 to 1974. She was a great boat shame about her end. After her bow got stoved in in the straits she was towed by the Navy stern first but too fast she sunk and they destroiyed her with depth charges due to the equipment she was fitted with "
Biscay or the Strait of Gibraltar?
Yer pays yer money and yer takes yer choice!😉
Cheers, Doug 😎
http://www.bmpt.co.uk/rttl-2754_topic736.html
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
As far as I would like to keep the boat original to its builder I am under no illusion that the Graupner 1713 is likely to be more trouble than it is worth and so I actually think the best way forward would be to replace it with a suitable new type motor, ESC and battery as a complete ‘matched’ power plant! I’m not worried about having it blitzing around the pond at ‘scale’ speed but more akin to a bit of performance matched by a good endurance.
So, what I really need from everyone is:
Which specific motor?
Which specific ESC?
Which specific battery type/pack
I already have five fully working 3s 2200 11.1v Lipo batteries in my armoury.
Thanks again.
PS we don’t talk about BA but the opposition, VA!😎
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
But Sabre or Sea Lion engines?
Container or no container; it can get pretty damn rough down there for a little boat or any ship!
What the heck was she doing there??
😎
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
2754 sank in the Bay of Biscay, thought to have collided with a floating container.
She was a Mk 1B, originally with 3 x Napier Sabre engines, shafts and props etc.
Most were later converted into the Mk 2 style with 2 x RR Griffons and 2 shafts etc.
Rowen
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
2754 was a Mk 1B RTTL; LoA 68', beam 19'.
So at 1:24 your model must be 34" LoA. Right?
Max speed was 40kn, cruising speed 33kn. See attached specs.
40kn is a very respectable speed so could be regarded as 'speed boat' 😉
See attached pics of 2754 underway.
Attached pics show her underway with at least her forefoot out of the wet stuff.
BUT pics 1 and 2 show what might happen if you have too much weight (SLA?) forward.🤔
The original boats had three shafts but I assume you are going to retain the single shaft for nostalgic reasons. OK👍
So you will need a fairly meaty motor, which I'm afraid that 1731 is not, and a battery and ESC that can deliver a reasonable current for a while.
That 1731 motor is rated at 6V, current draw On Load 3.3A, efficiency 43%, RPM OFF Load 4500. So I would expect a relatively sedate performance from it.🤔
To get anywhere near scale performance you will need to keep the boat as light as possible, i.e. NO SLA batteries!
So what is Scale Performance??
Rule of thumb is; square root of scale x max speed of original.
Here: scale 1/24, Max speed of original 40kn. So scale speed is (1/4.9)x40 = 8.1kn, which is a pretty fair trotting speed!
Frankly I don't believe that that motor is man enough. Three might have managed it though!
Personally I would go for a brushless motor; around 30xx/1000 to 1500kv, and 2S or 3S (7.4 or 11.1V nominal) LiPo battery but I appreciate your wish to keep the model true to the original builder👍
(Actually I would have rebuilt it for 3 shafts, but that's just me - I respect your wishes.)
And you may not want to get into the complications of LiPo batteries.
So if you retain that motor I would use a 5 cell 6V NiMh battery.
Given a 3.3A current draw an NiMh of around 6000mAh (6Ah) capacity should give you just under 2 hours running time.
More if you don't run full chat all the time😉
NiCads are very infra-dig these days due to the poisonous aspects of the cadmium. You'll probably have extreme trouble trying to buy them these days anyway. They have rotten self-discharge and memory effect characteristics as well.☹️
BUT: before you start connecting batteries and testing I would strongly recommend that you -
1 Dismantle and check the motor, seems to be just bolted together, check the brushes for wear and clean and polish the commutator - that's the copper bit with lots of segments that the brushes rest on 😁
Polish up with Brasso or ladies nail polish sticks. NOT a nail FILE, they are too rough.
When restoring vintage motors I first soak them in WD40 overnight to loosen up the bolts etc.
But in this case be careful to keep the WD40 away from the brushes - just in case they go soft 😭
At least oil the shaft bearings as Bill says before applying any volts to the motor!!
2 Dismantle the propshaft and check for wear at both ends, and rust at the prop end!
At the very least inject some light machine oil or even silicone grease before running any tests.
Re ESC: Given the current rating of the motor of 3.3A a 10or15Amp ESC should be more than enough; as Bill says Mtroniks Viper 10 or 15. Don't forget to fit a 5 or at most a10A fuse in case the prop gets stalled by weeds etc.
Apropos prop! I would change that for a 3 blade brass prop which is more in keeping with the originals.
For a 34" boat probably 35 or 40mm.
Bon chance mon ami👍
Cheers, Doug 😎
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
I am just wrapping one up. Am using a similar scale GF hull from MTBHulls fitted with 2 Brushless motors and a LIPO battery.
This gives good speed and she planes easily. Will be writing a brief blog shortly on this site.
Would agree with others, Lead acid batteries would be too heavy. Have not used NiCad, but been disappointed with NiMh.
Decided a couple of years ago to "standardize" on LiPo cells, as these give the best power density for weight. They do require carefull looking after, but find them worth the trouble.
There is a huge amount of information on the web. One site is RAFBoats, which has some very good pictures.
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
It’s great that your getting such a good balance of help and suggestions.
I agree 💯% with John re the battery.
I wouldn’t use the lead acid battery personally,primarily because of the weight. You would have to fit quite a lump centrally,and that probably will be a space problem.
Too far forward and you will end up with a submarine.Too far aft and you will have a speedboat!!
A good Nicad or Nimh will be just the job.
Again if you don’t have one they can be purchased from all the outlets aforementioned or on Amazon which is where I purchased two the other day at a cheaper price for the same product 👍👍.
Really would be good if you can do a refit blog to keep us all posted.
Regards Bill.
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
sidestickflyer
for my twopenneth worth, I myself would stick to what Scratchbuilder has suggested. Try and keep your model as original as possible. I googled the motor and came up with this link - https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?2582383-Graupner-Nautocraft-motor-voltage - and its an 'old' Graupner motor.
As far as using the 'old' lead acid batteries, I would steer away from them as much as possible - and try and go for the NiCad style batteries. They are lighter and also can take a bit more punishment.
If you go on to my profile on this website and have a look in the harbour, you will see I built the same model a while back.
I use 2 MTronik motors in mine; also the hull construction is extremely light. The other thing I have noticed about your model, the gent who built it, must have known about these particular boats as its the only model I have seen (apart from a few others) which incorporates the towing winch in the back cabin.
Let us know how you get on.
John
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Rick
https://www.cornwallmodelboats.co.uk/index.html
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
I was interested in your project as a long time ago I was a National Serviceman at Mountbatten ( Plymouth ) from May61 to April 62 where was an Air Wireless Fitter, we did not have any aeroplanes but the RAF boats were fitted with aircraft equipment. As I had been, prior to my enforced service to the Queen, employed in the aerospace industry, I had some technical drawing experience, consequently I became the only person in the drawing office, this was better than going round the boats doing the daily radio tests. My main task turned out to be to fit the new UHF radio to a RTTL, the intention of it was to locate and recover sono buoys. Because of the high frequency used the signal was very directional, so the RTTL was fitted with a pair of multi dipole aerials. I never saw the end of the project but I have a book " The RAF Air Sea Rescue Service 1918-1986" that has a picture of RTTL 2754 with these aerials, which I have attached ( sorry its upside down but I have forgot how to change it ).
I have been a member of this site for a long time and supposed to be building a HSL 100, but since the lock down and having got involved in too many other things it has not gone forward for some time, hopefully I shall get back to it. As far as I know RTTL 2757 is in the RAF museum at Hendon but I have not been there for a long time and it was in a sorry state last time I saw it. From my other interest in aerospace museums, the arts university educated curators being put into positions of power are buggering up our heritage and destroying priceless items with their "political correct" activities, so it is even more important that us model makers keep up the good work. There is one thing about model boats is they last, look at all the Fire Boats there are about still and they were the inspiration of this wonderful Web Site, it reminds me I had better make a donation.
Good luck with your restoration.
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
It’s a pleasure.
My choice would be the Mtroniks Viper Marine 15 “Brushed” for your motor.
These are readily available from most outlets.
They are advertised in Model Boat Magazine if you take it and lots of on line suppliers such as Howes Models of Kidlington.Cornwall Model Boats.Ebay(although don’t buy second hand) Model Boat bits etc or of course from your local model shop if you still have one near where you live.
Please remember this is my personal choice and there are many other excellent products out there.
Regards Bill
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
The model is so beautiful and obviously built with such love and devotion that I don’t want to do anything to it that I don’t need to in honour of its builder 60 years ago.
What would be your absolute choice of ESC? Manufacturer/model number?
Thanks in anticipation 👍
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Looks like a nice little project.
Personally I would stay with the original motor if it is in good order.
It sounds as if you havn’t done a test as yet,so my advice would be disconnect motor from the prop shaft (this will reduce the load on the motor) particularly if the shaft is a bit rusted or old oil clogged.
Without running for some time the motor bearings will probably be dry so if possible a very small amount of very light oil on the bearings and rotate first by hand to let it run around the motor shaft.(literally a wipe over with a cotton bud soaked in oil will be good.
Then try the motor on a 3 volt run and let it gently settle itself.
If your happy then after a 15 min run up the power and see how it performs.
Gently gently is the answer.
I do suggest that you remove the prop shaft and clean the tube and shaft and pack with light oil or waterproof grease(plenty out there on the market)
Pop it all back together and re run it in.
If the motor does not work then go to plan B,ie new motor.
Re the battery a good Nimh will be fine.
There are many speed controllers on the market.
I like the Mtroniks,but have many other types.The Viper would be more than man enough I would have thought.
Most important thing with this is,as it’s not run for a long time treat her gently to save damage.
Good luck.
Keep us posted.
Regards Bill
Ps.I am always happy to stand corrected.
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Vic Smead? Vosper RAF RTTL 2754 Restoration
Apparently it was hand built by a WWII naval veteran down in Plymouth probably in the early 1960’s and research suggests that it was almost certainly from the Vic Smead plan featured in Model Maker December 1958.
So, the plan is to fix a few broken parts (most of them are beautiful brass) and then fit some new R/C equipment and get it back sailing again.
I need your help! At present it is fitted with its original Graupner Nauto Craft 1731 6v electric motor. It has free movement but I’ve no idea yet if it actually functions.
So, if this was your boat would you?
a. Leave the original motor in place and fit a new speed controller and battery (what types please?)
or
b. Replace with a new motor, speed controller and battery? Again, which motor, ESC and battery?
I’m totally open for advice and equipment suggestions.
Thanks 👍
Liked by
Loading…