Question of the Day?
Hello everyone.
Let's start by saying that I've gotten it wrong in the past. Today I guessed right, but I think the question is poorly phrased.
I don't like the way the question was worded, and I had trouble understanding it even the first time.
I may have simply had problems interpreting the translation, and only the answer options help a little.
In my opinion, it's always important to specify who is upwind (or downwind) versus who. In short, it's a relative, not an absolute, position.
I've made this simple argument:
Whoever is upwind (in sailing, obviously, not in motor sailing) always has a tactical advantage over whoever is maneuvering downwind.
So much so that it's a universal rule to give precedence to whoever is downwind when sailing on a collision course on identical tacks.
In a battle, maneuverability is often the most determining factor.
In theory, I also agree with Luckyduck's reasoning and consideration. This option, however, isn't considered among the four possible ones.
I don't think A, B, and C are correct, they are all highly incorrect in my opinion, including B.