Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Started by AtreiusModels
15 replies 46 likes Last activity: 3 years ago
#16

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Hi Atreius Models, Good to hear you have isolated one of the power leads. If your ESC has an on off switch it should still be used as I have damaged an Mtronik Esc in a multi-prop model by failing to switch on both ESC's. I use three on my Olympic and have a panel with the three switches side by side so I can easily see all are on or off.
dave976
Liked by AtreiusModels and Doogle and
#15

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Hi Rodc give me a small while, the drawing is not to hand at the moment, when I find it I will copy it to you.
I used a circuit published in the now defunct Model Cars, an off-shoot of Model Maker magazine.
But BEC's are so cheap now I would not bother to make my own any more.
Regards
Roy
Liked by Scratchbuilder and dave976
#14

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

In my experience, forget about using two Mtroniks esc’s together even if a red wire is removed from one of them. I even used an Mtroniks optical isolator to eliminate stray cross current interference. To no avail; both of them failed just north of immediately. Mtroniks tech folks were extremely helpful trying to resolve the issue but finally said they could not figure out a solution. Mtroniks esc’s are superior when used singly but I will never again try them in tandem.
Just describing what I faced with the twin installation in my avatar boat.😔
Liked by Scratchbuilder and dave976 and
#13

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Thank you very much everyone for your help, I'll remove the red (+ve) cable from the 10A ESC as this seems to be the simplest option given both ESCs have a built in BEC.

@RNinMunich I currently have 2, Bizmork and a smaller but similarly themed one named Gork's Revenge. You can find photos of both on the linked Facebook page. I plan to upload photos of Gork's Revenge here when I find the time to modify/rebuild her.
It was my first 'proper' attempt at building a model boat and I've learned a great deal since building her and want to go back and redo the internals including as big a motor as I can squeeze in for towing.
Liked by Scratchbuilder and dave976
#12

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Roycv a schematic wud be more explicit. You cud draw it black on white paper, then photograph it & attach it to your post. Despite all my electronics experience i cant envision what you just said.
Best regards, Rod
VA3ROD
Liked by dave976
#11

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

BEC Battery Eliminator Circuit. I used to make my own. Just a small power transistor and a Zener diode a couple of resistors and a plug to go into Rx.
The Zener diode is 0.7 volts below the required voltage. A battery the other end, could be the drive battery. All mounted on a small veroboard maybe a LED to show it was working.
With this circuit as the voltage decreases it does not switch off suddenly
Roy
Liked by dave976
#9

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

I agree with RNinMunich - only one power source to your ESC, but rather than chop the wire off, just disconnect it at the plug and tape it back. In that way it can be used again if ever needed. To disconnect you just need to use a needle to depress the sprung tang, then carefully withdraw the wire from the plug. 😉
Liked by Len1 and roycv and
#8

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

When modifying the leads for extra (multiple) ESCs (battery eliminator circuit) I usually take only a small amount of the red wire out, somewhere not too close to the connector or ESC. Gap needs to be only a few MM. Then insulate the cut (electrical tape...). This way you can re-use the ESC by re-connecting the wire.
Lew
Florida, USA
Lew
Florida, USA
Home page: https://www.RCFlorida.org/lmb
Liked by dave976 and RogerA1 and
#6

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Sorry TD, I guess I kinda took that as read!😔

😎
Young at heart 😉 Slightly older in other places.😊 Cheers Doug
Liked by dave976 and ToraDog
#5

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

What Doug said... except I tape off the red wires. One never knows what the future might bring....😊
Liked by dave976 and Len1 and
#4

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Hi AM,
To cut to the chase ...
Golden rule is ONLY ONE power source for the receiver, whether from a BEC or a separate battery ONLY ONE. Otherwise you risk potential damage 🔥 to either the receiver or one (or more) of the BECs/ESCs.
So choose the strongest of the BECs and chop 😮🙈 the red wires of the rest.
Happy sailing👍
Cheers, Doug😎
Young at heart 😉 Slightly older in other places.😊 Cheers Doug
Liked by Len1 and dave976 and
#3

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

PS: It is not important if the ESC's use separate batteries. What matters is that they are electronically controlled by the same receiver, which can tolerate only one BEC connected to it.
Liked by dave976 and Len1 and
#2

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

Whenever running more than one ESC THAT IS EQUIPPED WITH BEC's, the red lead in the servo lead from the ESC should be removed. This ensures that only one BEC feeds the required current to the receiver.
My current build uses five ESC's, all equipped with BEC's, but because of the current requirements for the # of servos each receiver drives, I am using stand alone BEC's. Therefore the red lead on all of the ESC servo leads is removed. Hope that is not too confusing.😀
Liked by Len1 and dave976 and
#1

Using 2 Mtronik ESCs

A question for the model boat hive mind please. I have a model with 2 Mtroniks ESCs, 1 is 25amps running everything and a 10 amp one running a smoke unit.
Each one is connected to a 5500mAh 3S 35C Lipo, do I need to disconnect the red power cable from the 10 amp ESC or is this only necessary when running 2 matching ESCs (with separate batteries connected to each) that have been mixed for running a twin prop vessel?
Liked by Len1 and dave976 and

Sign in to add to this thread.

Delete this post?

It will be removed from the site.

Discard this draft?

Your draft will be deleted and cannot be recovered.

You have an unfinished draft

What would you like to do with it?